Proposed Plan Public Comments [August 2014]
The public comments that EPA received are available on EPA's web site, FOIAOnline.regulations.gov, at this
The majority of the comments are combined into one file named "PP Comments Combined_09 25 2014". The comments
submitted by Tierra/Maxus/Occidental and the Cooperating Parties Group were too large to be completely loaded
onto any web site, and so were handled as detailed below. If you would like to receive a complete electronic
version of all of the comments (except for the copyrighted materials discussed below), please send a request
to Alice Yeh at firstname.lastname@example.org.
- The comments submitted by Tierra/Maxus/Occidental are in the file named "MASTER PDF - EXECUTIVE SUMMARY (Electronic Version)",
except for two folders of materials referenced in the comments: 1) non-copyrighted materials, which are listed in the file
"Non-Copyrighted Reference List"; and 2) copyrighted materials, which are journal articles listed in the references at the
end of each section of comments.
- The comments submitted by the Cooperating Parties Group are in the files named "CPG_FFS_Comments_Submitted_8_20_14",
"Transmittal Letter" and "List_of_Documents_for_the_Administrative_Record", except for 7 folders of materials referenced
in the text (listed in the references at the end of each section of comments).
- Copyrighted materials submitted with the comments are available for review in the EPA Region 2 Superfund Records
Center at 290 Broadway, 18th Floor, New York, NY 10007. Please call the Records Center at 212-637-4308 to make an appointment.
Final Remedial Investigation Report and Focused Feasibility Study [April 2014]
The Remedial Investigation Report (RI) describes the nature and extent of contamination in the sediments of the lower 8
miles of the Lower Passaic River and the risks to human health and the environment posed by exposure to that contamination.
The Focused Feasibility Study (FFS) evaluates a range options to clean up the contaminated sediments in the lower 8 miles
(called remedial alternatives). The files that are part of the RI and FFS can be downloaded and reviewed by clicking on the links below:
Remedial Investigation Report (RI Report)
Focused Feasibility Study Report (FFS Report)
Appendix A (Data Evaluation Reports)
There have been some problems reported when downloading Appendix A. For convenience, links to the individual data evaluation reports are provided below.
Appendix A Individual Reports:
Appendix B (Modeling):
Appendix C (Mass Balance Modeling Analysis)
Appendix D (Risk Assessment)
Appendix E (Preliminary Remediation Goals)
Appendix F (Engineering Evaluations)
Appendix G (Dredged Material Management Assessments)
Appendix H (Cost Estimates)
The RI and FFS provide information that supports the Proposed Plan, described and available for download on the “Home” page.
The figures that are part of the Proposed Plan are attached to the
text and available for download on the “Home” page. However, the text
also refers to certain figures in the RI, FFS and appendices that the
reader may want to review for more in-depth information.
Those figures have been gathered here for convenience:
RI-FFS-Appendix Figures for Proposed Plan.
Additional fact sheets related to the FFS and Proposed Plan are posted in the Digital Library, under Public Outreach\Fact Sheets.
Meetings Held During the Public Comment Period [April 2014 through August 2014]
Following are meetings held during the public comment period between EPA and non-governmental stakeholders that included substantive
discussions regarding the Proposed Plan and Focused Feasibility Study. These meetings are being documented in accordance with EPA’s
Superfund Community Involvement Handbook (EPA 540-K-05-003) and will become part of the administrative record. Agendas and/or notes
from the meetings are available in the Digital Library, under “All Public Documents”, “Passaic River Lower 8 Mile Action” folder.
Passaic River Community Advisory Group materials are available under “Public Outreach\Community Advisory Group”.
EPA Public Meetings:
- Newark Public Meeting in Newark, NJ on May 7, 2014 at 7:00 PM
- Kearny Public Meeting in Kearny, NJ on May 21, 2014 at 6:00 PM
- Belleville Public Meeting in Belleville, NJ on June 23, 2014 at 2:00 PM
Meetings Open to the Public Sponsored by Others:
- Montclair State University Morning Dialogue in Montclair, NJ on June 2, 2014 at 8:00 AM
- Ironbound Community Corporation "Restoring Our River" forum in Newark, NJ on June 10, 2014 at 6:00 PM
- NY-NJ Harbor & Estuary Program Citizens Advisory Committee Meeting in Newark, NJ on June 12, 2014 at 2:00 PM
(notes prepared by the HEP are available at http://www.harborestuary.org/citadvcomm.htm)
- Passaic River Community Advisory Group Meeting in Newark, NJ on June 12, 2014 at 6:00 PM
- New Jersey Institute of Technology Forum in Newark, NJ on July 22, 2014 at 9:00 AM (dredged material disposal) and 1:00 PM (navigation channel)
- Meeting with private entities in Washington, DC on May 29, 2014 at 10:00 AM
- Meeting with non-governmental entities in Washington, DC on August 4, 2014 at 4:30 PM
Final Lower Passaic River Commercial
Navigation Analysis [July 2010]
This document presents the current status of
commercial navigation use on the Lower Passaic River.
The previous two drafts (March 2007 and December 2008)
have been updated to reflect input provided by
commercial users of the navigation channel. To review
this report, please
Sampling Activities to Support the Early
A sampling event has been planned to gather data to
support the Empirical Mass Balance Model in the FFS.
Attached are the work plan documents that describe the
sampling. Please click here to download the
Quality Assurance Project Plan (QAPP)/Field Sampling
Plan (FSP) Addendum and
Sediment Trap Amendment.
Sampling has been planned in the surface sediments of
River Mile 0 - 1 to fill in data gaps for the Early
Action evaluation. Attached are the work plan documents
that describe the sampling. Please
click here to download the QAPP Modification, figure
Sampling and lab experiments are being planned to
determine Passaic River sediment erosion rates using a
device named "Sedflume". Erosion rates will be used in
sediment transport modeling to characterize sediment
stability or the potential for sediments to move.
Click here to download the QAPP Modification.
Draft Focused Feasibility Study (FFS) [June, 2007]
The Focused Feasibility Study (FFS) evaluates a range
of alternatives that might be implemented to control the
sediments of the lower eight miles of the Passaic River.
A draft FFS is being reviewed by the Remedial Options
Work Group. The files that comprise the draft FFS can be
downloaded and reviewed by clicking on the links below:
Draft FFS Executive Summary
Draft FFS Executive Summary and Text
Draft FFS Figures and Tables
Draft FFS Appendix A Conceptual Site Model
Draft FFS Appendix B Sediment TBCs and PRGs
Draft FFS Appendix C Risk Assessment
Draft FFS Appendix D Empirical Mass Balance Model
Draft FFS Appendix E Engineering Memoranda
Draft FFS Appendix F Navigation Studies
Draft FFS Appendix G Cap Erosion and Flood Modeling
Draft FFS Appendix H Dredged Material Management
Draft FFS Appendix I Dredging Volume Estimates
Draft FFS Appendix J Cost Estimates
On June 27, 2007, the Remedial Options Work Group
heard an overview of the draft FFS. The files that
comprise the overview can be downloaded and reviewed by
clicking on the links below:
Remedial Options Workgroup Presentation -
Remedial Options Workgroup Presentation - CSM and
Remedial Options Workgroup Presentation - Risk.pdf
Remedial Options Workgroup Presentation -
Note that the due date for comments from the work
group recently was extended to August 16, 2007 from the
date shown in the presentations.
On May 7, 2008, the Remedial Options Work Group met
to hear an update on work being done to address comments
on the draft FFS. The discussion focused on how the
remedial alternatives would be updated (click
here for the presentation).